Monthly Writings

Evaluations and reviews of the latest in the field.

Chief Financial Officer’s Perspective of Telemedicine

SUMMARY:

  • Telemedicine implementation and operation involves significant financial considerations.

  • Most CFO’s view telemedicine as a loss leader or at best a neutral impact program.

  • CFO’s do identify several direct and indirect financial benefits of telemedicine programs.


BACKGROUND

  • Health system decisions to invest in telemedicine programs is a complex one.

  • Research on telemedicine programs has historically focused on clinician and/or patient input.

  • As part of the decision making group, the CFO’s perspective is necessary.

REVIEW

General Considerations

  • Telemedicine implementation and operations involve significant financial considerations.

  • Expenses of such a program are primarily due to:

    • Technology and infrastructure

    • Staffing

    • Workflow integration

    • Education/training

    • Outreach

  • Most CFO’s believe telemedicine is a loss leader or at best a neutral impact on health system finances.

  • Although reimbursement of telemedicine is increasing, it remains variable and inconsistent.

Key Challenges to Telemedicine Financial Viability

  • Substantial technology investment

    • Subsequent long term financial benefits are difficult to quantify on a spreadsheet.

    • Use of telemedicine services and return on investment downstream is hard to determine.

  • Low volumes and low reimbursement prevent telemedicine from being profitable.

    • Must factor in:

      • Non-technology costs

      • Unknown future reimbursement rates

  • There are few examples of telemedicine services with direct financial advantages

  • Telemedicine is not a predominantly featured item during strategic planning.

  • Belief that in-person care is superior to virtual-care.

     

Direct Financial Benefits are Possible Based on:

  • The primary goal is to improve quality of care, not financial.

  • Improved patient retention and prevent transfers.

  • Financial benefit tied to increases in patient volumes

    • Many CFO’s are only convinced once the program is actually completed

  • The program may drive additional ancillary services

    • Laboratory services

    • Referrals to other services and providers

  • Keeping up with local competitors rather than improve financial position

  • Telemedicine is less expensive than adding brick & mortar beds or hiring full time providers.

    • Decrease direct labor costs

    • Decrease cost of recruiting

Financial Considerations

 Keys to Getting the Full Benefit from a Telemedicine Investment

  • Switch from Defense to Offense.

    • Change from defending operating margins and volumes to looking for areas of growth via revenue diversification.

  • Get Up and Running

    • Maximizing the full value from the telemedicine program  is a long term effort

    • It will not happen in the first 1 or 2 quarters, may take 1 – 2 years.

    • Get up and running at least in a rudimentary way.

  • Meet Patients Where They Are.

    • CFO’s and healthcare leaders need to get more comfortable with ambulatory and virtual models of care.

    • Being more responsive to patients via e-consults and e-clinics.

  • Expand Capacity

    • Keep adding key components, in a way to take the burden off employees

    • Ensure the technology meets all the clinical needs

  • Maximize Clinical Use

    • Become a high-end user of whatever digital health area or technology the health system focuses on.

  • Maximize Data and Analytics

    • Become more analytical.

    • Benchmark over time the major clinical and financial outcomes

      • By Practice area

      • By Provider

Benefit from Telemedicine Investment

CONCLUSIONS:

  • CFO’s typically perceive telemedicine as not being able to improve their health systems financial profile.

  • CFO’s may be motivated to implement telemedicine programs to improve quality of care.

  • Telemedicine financial advantages do exist by increasing local revenue from ancillary services and fewer transfers.

  • Financial performance is positively impacted by increased volumes (i.e. bed turnover).

Erkan Hassan